ScrappleFace500.gif
Top Headlines...
:: Arafat May Soon Sign Death Certificate
:: Specter Backs Ashcroft for Next Supreme Court Opening
:: NJ Gov. McGreevey Leaves Office with Mandate
:: Specter Backs Partial-Burial Abortion for Arafat
:: Specter Retracts Ill-Conceived Abortion Remarks
:: Bush Swats Kofi Annan with Rolled Newspaper
:: Arafat Burial Plans Done in Time for Final Death
:: P. Diddy Survives 'Vote or Die' Attempt
:: Kerry Plan: White House Run Hid True Ambition
:: Bush Declares End of Major Campaign Operations

October 19, 2002
Congress May Mandate 'Fisking' Royalties

(2002-10-19) -- Webloggers who engage in 'Fisking' may soon pay royalties to Independent columnist Robert Fisk for the privilege, if Congress approves a bill introduced this week.

Popularized by Glenn Reynolds of InstaPundit.com, 'Fisking' has become the heart of the news weblog culture. Unfortunately, Mr. Fisk himself has received little from the use of his name.

"Although I have become famous beyond anything I deserve," said Mr. Fisk, "All of this so-called 'Fisking' doesn't bring me a shilling."

According to weblogger Eugene Volokh, Fisking means "a thorough and forceful verbal beating of an anti-war, possibly anti-American, commentator who has richly earned this figurative beating through his words. Good Fisking tends to be (or at least aim to be) quite logical, and often quotes the other article in detail, interspersing criticisms with the original article's text."

The term was born after Mr. Fisk took an actual beating from some anti-American Afghans, and wrote that he understood, and couldn't blame them.

Under the bill's provisions, webloggers would pay 7-cents per site visitor for each Fisking.

The only hope for Fiskers is that U.S. Sen. Jesse Helms, R-NC, would delay the bill like he has the bill that would force webcasters to pay back royalties for music played online.

by Scott Ott | Donate | | Comments (22) | More Satire | Printer-Friendly
Buy "Axis of Weasels," the first book by Scott Ott. $12.95 + S&H;
Email this entry to: Your email address:
Message (optional):
Skip to Comments Form

scott you are so funny.

hey, but what about robert bork? doesn't he get a penny everytime somebody gets borked?

Posted by: skippy at October 19, 2002 10:51 PM

Yes, Skippy, Robert Bork does indeed get a penny everytime someone gets "borked", just as the President's family gets a penny everytime a tired person announces "I'm bushed" (damn-- I owe them BOTH some money now-- thanks Skip!).

The problem with giving this deal to Fisk as I see it (unless I'm missing something) is that he's a darned foreigner! The bill-- as proposed-- is therefore, unAmerican-- just like the "Rupert Murdoch protection law" that ended the foreign ownership restrictions on t.v. stations (and t.v. has sucked ever since) and the original GOP resistance to efficient federal control of air safety (the main airport security contractors were British and Swedish).

And now, once again: lobbyists for foreigners cutting themselves a sweetheart deal in Congress, at the expense of real Americans.

It makes me sick.

Posted by: the talking dog at October 19, 2002 11:13 PM

McDermott & Bonior sponsored the bill in the house, Leahy & Hegel in the Senate. Be sure to thank them, Dog.

Posted by: Porphyrogenitus at October 19, 2002 11:18 PM

The P-family also benefits from this.

Ambushed: A War Reporter's Life on the Line

Posted by: George Brody at October 19, 2002 11:28 PM

Well, this certainly seems a little odd... Fisking is, after all, critique of an article. I'm unfamiliar with copyright laws, but my common sense tells me that quoting the sentence you have something to say about is perfectly normal, and does not require any special permission from the author of that statement. Does Roger Ebert or the Chicago Sun-Times have to pay royalties every time he quotes a line from a movie in his reviews?

And Fisk is getting more and more deranged... 'Yes, people have been saying 'That Fisk is a moron' for years, and I've yet to see a penny of royalties from the use of my name'. He should be glad that he's helped enrich the english language.

Posted by: Sam Muldia at October 19, 2002 11:35 PM

Err... 'More News Satire'?

Oh damn, I feel embarrassed now. I think I'll go make myself a hat that says DUNCE or something.

In my defense, I have never been on scrappleface before. Which of course is a crime in itself, so I guess I'll just make myself scarce now.

Posted by: Sam Muldia at October 19, 2002 11:42 PM

Sam, I hesitate to say this, but don't feel embarrassed. Your mistake made me laugh, and I so very much needed that laugh tonight, as the news is rather grim in my neck of the woods tonight.

Thanks, Scott and Sam. I needed that.

Posted by: Meryl Yourish at October 19, 2002 11:46 PM

Robert Fisk is a self-hating westerner, whose take on anything is usually the opposite of the truth. Why then, do people accept Fisk's take on his beating? If you read that story, he didn't have any problem until he started speaking Arabic. The Afghans, IMHO, hated the Arabs, who dominated their country and their government and ran around like Pashas in their country.

Second point, does Robert Bork get a penny whenever 'borking' is used? ;^)

Posted by: Jabba the Tutt at October 19, 2002 11:49 PM

Great! The royalty rate means that based on my site's readership, Fisk gets, ummm . . . carry the one . . . equals . . . 14 cents.

That's it. I'm broke.

Posted by: Bill Peschel at October 20, 2002 12:05 AM

It's all OK: after we've paid up, we can beat him up and take his money. He is, after all, asking for it by being rich, white, and protected by the law...

Posted by: The Philosophical Cowboy at October 20, 2002 05:29 AM

I say,allow Fisk the royalties but have John Malkovich be in charge of the disbursement.

Posted by: Marc Savoy at October 20, 2002 07:18 AM

If this passes, I am doomed. But then again, the phrase "squeezing blood from a rock" comes to mind. Stop me before I Fisk again!

Posted by: Mike at October 20, 2002 09:44 AM

...snip...the phrase "squeezing blood from a rock" comes to mind

Remember, you cannot get blood from a turnip but it can be fun giving the turnip a fit.

Regards (and do I owe Mike 7 cents?)

Posted by: John Johns at October 20, 2002 10:28 AM

Great, Mike! Now you owe "The Rock" money> (oops! so do I). Oh, well . . .

Posted by: JorgXMcKie at October 20, 2002 12:42 PM

Of course, Fisk is welcome to 10% of everything I make out of my site...

Posted by: The Philosophical Cowboy at October 20, 2002 03:36 PM

I want $1 every time somebody does any math using one of these or buys one of these. Retroactive to my birth (1959) and continuing for my estate until 100 years after my death.

Posted by: Jay Manifold at October 20, 2002 06:17 PM

Don't forget Fisk also said he[fisk] would have beaten me[fisk] too; so I guess he means that those who get fisked, not only deserve it but are asking for it. Can't feel soory when those getting a good see-ing too get more than they bargained for.

Posted by: myron at October 20, 2002 09:57 PM

May I suggest to all my UK friends that you know have use for all the shillings lying around in your pots.

Posted by: Jack at October 21, 2002 04:58 AM

Surely the Afgans who beat up Fisk were not 'anti american'? That would make no sense. The whole point is that they beat him up because he opposed the american action which rid their benighted country of the loathesome taliban?

Posted by: nick mallory at October 21, 2002 05:45 AM

Only now, at the end of his career, do we begin to understand the value of Jesse!

Posted by: Bob at October 21, 2002 08:40 AM

MommaBear would suggest that Blogdom resort to the well-know "Dodge" [grin] of subsituting an * for the first ' i ' in f*sking, thus protecting the membership, and, at the same time, placing said term in the category of all those other 'socially unacceptable' words.

F*sk on, fellow bloggers !!

Posted by: MommaBear at October 21, 2002 03:41 PM

Oops, I thought 'f*sking' was something totally different, something, ummm.... something you don't discuss in mixed company.

But in my defense, I do type with a lisp....

Wow! All those stories make MUCH more sense now!

Posted by: Eric Cox at October 22, 2002 03:26 AM
0A
100 Recent Comments
Access the 100 most recent ScrappleFace reader comments, with links to the stories and to commenter archives.
ScrappleFace Headlines